Umami is small, friendly and MIT licensed. It runs as one container with a Postgres database, and it has grown a lot since version 3, with funnels, retention, journeys, revenue and visitor profiles. So why look elsewhere? Usually it's one of three things, and the first is that running the server yourself gets old. The free cloud plan runs out, since Hobby covers 100,000 events on one website with six months of data and no API. Or you want something it doesn't do.
Be fair to it first. Umami Pro costs $20 a month for 1 million events, which is less than almost anything below. Business is $200 at 10 million and adds session replay.
We checked each tool on its own pricing page or docs in October and November 2026. Umami's and Fathom's figures were rechecked on 13 November.
The short answer
Plausible is the nearest match if you liked Umami for being simple and cookieless. Fathom is the same idea, closed. Rybbit is the pick if you self-host and want replay as well, and Matomo is for teams that need every row on their own servers with a lot of depth behind it.
Start with Spreelytics if you'd rather host nothing and want revenue by channel. It's free up to 1 million events.
At a glance
| Tool | Best for | Free plan | At 1M a month | Open source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spreelytics | Traffic, product and revenue with nothing to host | 1M events | $0 (Free) | No |
| Plausible | Simple, cookieless, EU-hosted | No, 30-day trial | $69 / $104 / $139 | Yes, AGPL |
| Fathom | Simple, with nothing to run | No, 7-day trial | $60 | No |
| Rybbit | Replay and errors you can host | No, 7-day trial | $69 / $139 | Yes, AGPL |
| Simple Analytics | Storing nothing personal | 1 month of history | $60 | Scripts only |
| Matomo | Every row on your own server | Free to self-host | €172 (Cloud) | Yes, GPL |
| GoatCounter | Personal sites, for free | Free for reasonable use | Free | Yes, EUPL |
| Umami, for reference | Easy to self-host | 100k events, 1 site | $20 (Pro) | Yes, MIT |
Plausible's three prices are Starter, Growth and Business, and Rybbit's two are Standard and Pro.
1. Spreelytics
We make Spreelytics, so read this entry with that in mind.
One script sends one stream of events. The traffic side has sources, campaigns, pages and countries, and the product side has goals, funnels, retention, journeys, segments and a timeline for each person. Payments from Stripe, Paddle, Polar or Lemon Squeezy are credited to the channel that earned them. You pick last-touch or linear, on the free plan too. We count AI crawlers on your server, which a page script never sees. And an MCP server lets Claude, ChatGPT or Cursor read your reports and build new ones when you ask in a chat window.
Where Umami wins: it's open source and you can host it, where we're closed source and hosted only. Its script is smaller than ours. At 10 million events Umami Business is $200 a month, where we're $339. Replay needs our Growth plan.
Pricing: free up to 1 million events a month with unlimited projects and members, the API and MCP included, and 13 months of data. Growth starts at $59. See Spreelytics vs Umami.
2. Plausible
Plausible is the closest in spirit, with a light script, no cookies and one clean dashboard, hosted in the EU. It's open source under AGPL, and the Community Edition is free to host yourself. Data is kept for as long as you pay.
The catch is the plan you need. Funnels, revenue goals and the Stats API sit on Business, and that's $139 a month at 1 million pageviews. Starter is $9 a month for 10,000.
Pricing: a 30-day trial with no card, then from $9 a month. See Spreelytics vs Plausible.
3. Fathom
Cookieless analytics with an EU isolation option, kept simple on purpose. Every feature is on every plan. Each plan covers 50 sites, and you can add more in packs of 50 at $10 a month. Nothing is open source, so there is no self-hosted version.
Pricing: $15 a month at 100,000 pageviews, $60 at 1 million and $200 at 10 million. The trial is 7 days and asks for a card. See Spreelytics vs Fathom.
4. Rybbit
The newest tool here. Rybbit adds session replay, error tracking and page speed to cookieless web analytics, and it's open source under AGPL. Run it on your own box or use its EU cloud. Standard has funnels, journeys and retention. Pro adds replay.
Pricing: a 7-day trial, then $69 a month at 1 million pageviews on Standard or $139 on Pro. Paying yearly takes four months off. See Spreelytics vs Rybbit.
5. Simple Analytics
A Dutch service that stores nothing personal, not even an IP address. The dashboard is plain. Only its tracking scripts are open source.
Pricing: free for 5 sites with one month of history and a badge on your site. Paid plans start at $20 a month, and it was $60 at 1 million datapoints in October. See Spreelytics vs Simple Analytics.
6. Matomo
The old hand. Matomo has been around for more than a decade. Goals and ecommerce come free, with funnels, attribution, cohorts, heatmaps and recordings as paid plugins. The On-Premise edition is free forever under GPL. It's a much bigger thing to run than Umami, though.
Pricing: free to self-host. Matomo Cloud has a 21-day trial and was €172 a month at 1 million hits in October. See Spreelytics vs Matomo.
7. GoatCounter
For a blog or a personal site, GoatCounter may be all you need. It's free on goatcounter.com for reasonable public use, paid for by donations, and you can host it yourself. Visits are counted even with JavaScript off. It counts pages and little else, so there are no funnels, profiles or revenue.
Pricing: free. Millions of pageviews a day is past what it's for. See Spreelytics vs GoatCounter.
Which to pick
- You liked Umami for being small and cookieless: Plausible or Fathom.
- You want to keep self-hosting, with replay: Rybbit.
- Your data has to stay on your own servers, with depth: Matomo.
- It's a personal site and you want to pay nothing: GoatCounter.
- You'd rather host nothing, and revenue matters: Spreelytics.
For prices side by side, see web analytics pricing compared. The wider field is in the best Google Analytics alternatives.